-
All incoming articles are reviewed! The term of reviewing the article is not more than 4 months.
-
Referee can be members of the editorial board of the journal, employees of Reshetnev University, as well as scientists from other universities and scientific organizations who are recognized experts on the subject of peer-reviewed materials.
-
The journal adopted the system of single blind (anonymous) review: referee knows the name of author, author does not know the name of referee. There are three or more referees for all articles in each issue. All contacts between an author and a referee are made through the editorial staff. The finished review is sent to the author by e-mail.
-
Each referee has the right to refuse to review if there is a clear conflict of interest, reflected in the perception and interpretation of the manuscript materials. Following the review of the manuscript, the referee makes recommendations on the article (each decision of the referee is justified):
- the article is recommended for publication in this form;
- the article is recommended for publication after corrections of the deficiencies noted by the referee;
- the article needs additional review by another specialist;
- the article can not be published in the journal.
-
If the referee has comments, the article is returned to the author for correcting. After correcting comments, the author re-sent the article to the referee.
-
In case if the authors refuse to correct the materials, they must notify the editorial office in writing or orally of their refusal to publish the article. If the authors do not return the corrected material after 3 months from the day the review was sent, even in the absence of information from the authors with refusal to correct the article, the editors remove it from the register. In such situations, the authors are sent a corresponding notice of the removal of the manuscript from the registration due to the expiration of the time allotted for correcting.
-
The articles received a positive review will be considered at the next meeting of the editorial staff, where a list of articles for the next issue will be prepared. If the number of articles exceeds the stated volume of the journal, the articles, which were not included, will remain in the editorial portfolio until the next meeting. Editorial board meetings are held on the 20th of every second month of the quarter.
-
In case of receiving a negative review, a motivated refusal is sent to the author. In case of disagreement with the opinion of the reviewer, the author of the article has the right to provide a reasoned answer to the editors of the journal At the next meeting of the editorial board, a decision will be made either to send the article to another reviewer, or to reject it. The article rejected by the editorial board is not re-accepted. Materials (article and documents) are not returned to the author.
-
The editorial board makes the final decision on the publication of the article with a positive review. In conflict situations, the decision is made by the chief editor
-
Reviews and expert reports are kept in the journal’s editorial office for 5 years.
The editorial office of the journal sends copies of reviews to the Ministry of Education and Science of the Russian Federation upon request.